ALDI SÜD will rule the grocery market. That's my bet, and here is why Walmart has no chance.
It's astonishing, because marketing was not only invented in the USA. Great marketing practices are always implemented years ahead in Europe. In grocery, the major players have now gone too far.
The $7.49 Box of Cereal
A post went viral on X. A US shopper pulled a $4.99 box of cereal off the shelf, took it to the register and watched the scanner ring it up at $7.49. The cashier explained: that's the digital coupon price. Download the store app, create an account, search for the item and clip the coupon before scanning.
His reaction: you inflated the shelf price by 50%, locked the normal price behind an app, and forced me to hand over my phone data and email just to pay the actual retail value of a box of food. Stop hiding basic shelf pricing behind data-harvesting apps.
I spent a few weeks in the US recently, and I can confirm it. It's a ridiculous experience to shop in virtually any supermarket there. That is one man's anecdote and mine, not a study. But it points at something bigger.
Europe Followed the Benchmark
The European chains introduced their apps in recent years and months, and followed the US "benchmark". Points, coupons, personalised offers, the whole loyalty stack.
Only that it doesn't work.
Independent studies, such as from the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, show that these loyalty systems may keep buyers "loyal". Actually, not loyal: trapped. But at the same time they make it harder to acquire new customers. The system is built to harvest the shoppers you already have. It is not built to win anyone who doesn't have the app.
Best practice is a recipe for the middle. When every chain copies the same playbook, the playbook stops being an advantage. It becomes the thing customers complain about.
ALDI Uses the Frustration
ALDI is the first big player that actually uses this growing frustration to its advantage. The line: "no app, still lowest prices". Or, in another version, "No points, no cards, no faff".
Read that as a marketer. It is not a feature. It is a promise built from what the competition makes customers put up with. Every sentence in it names a pain that shoppers of the other chains know by heart.
And it is credible, which is the part rivals can't copy quickly. ALDI reinvented grocery 70 years ago by optimising processes so that it can run, as I understand it, a 10% margin at market-leading prices. A chain with that cost base can afford to say "no points". A chain whose margin depends on data and coupon mechanics cannot.
Now ALDI reinvents what it means to be customer-centric. Not by adding something. By leaving out what shoppers hate.
Why Customers Didn't Tell the Chains
You might ask why the other grocers didn't see this coming. Run a survey and shoppers will say they like coupons. Of course they do. Money off is a fine thing to be asked about. What a survey won't show is the slow irritation of standing at a register while a price changes. That's the say-do gap at work, and part of why customers can't tell you why they buy, or why they walk away.
Frustration lives below the stated answer. You have to look for it indirectly.
Finding the frustration in your own category
- List what every competitor does the same way. That is where the playbook lives.
- Ask what customers put up with, not what they want. Stated wishes are polite. Tolerated annoyances are the opening.
- Check who the system is built for. Existing customers, or the ones you still need to win?
- Test credibility. Can your cost structure back the promise, the way ALDI's process advantage backs "no points"?
Clarity and Courage
It takes clarity and courage to go against the current. Clarity, because you must see which part of the category's habit your buyers resent. Courage, because dropping the loyalty app looks like giving up a lever every consultant in the industry will tell you to pull.
That is the same reflex I wrote about in NIVEA's category language trap: a brand that behaves like the category gets the growth of the category. And it is the opposite of the faster-cheaper trap, because ALDI doesn't win by copying the cheapest rival. It wins by removing a reason to be annoyed. For the wider logic of finding the one lever that moves demand, see growth strategy in a commoditized market.
Whether ALDI really rules the market is a prediction, and I'm happy to be checked on it. The principle holds either way.
What are the frustrations in your category? Are you bold enough to serve them, and to be the Robin Hood of your market?
ALDI, loyalty apps and category frustration: frequently asked questions
Why might ALDI beat Walmart in grocery?
Dr. Frank Buckler's view is that US-style loyalty apps have frustrated shoppers, and ALDI is the first big player to turn that frustration into positioning with lines such as "no app, still lowest prices". ALDI's process-driven cost base, which he understands to support a roughly 10% margin at market-leading prices, makes the promise credible. It is his prediction, not a proven outcome.
Do loyalty apps actually build loyalty?
According to Dr. Frank Buckler, independent studies such as those from the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute indicate that loyalty systems may keep existing buyers, but more trapped than truly loyal, while making it harder to acquire new customers. The programme is built to harvest the shoppers a chain already has, which can leave it weaker at winning shoppers who do not use the app.
How do you find the frustrations in your category?
List what every competitor does the same way, then look for what customers tolerate rather than what they say they want. Surveys give polite, stated answers. Frustration usually sits below them and needs indirect, implicit measurement. Then test credibility: your cost structure and capabilities must be able to back a promise that removes the annoyance.
What does the ALDI example teach about positioning?
Strong positioning can be built by leaving out what the category makes customers put up with. ALDI's "No points, no cards, no faff" is a promise assembled from competitors' pain points. It works because ALDI's operating model supports it, so rivals that depend on data and coupon mechanics cannot copy it quickly.
Dr. Frank Buckler advises leadership teams on growth decisions that depend on why customers choose. He founded SUPRA, holds a PhD in marketing and was among the first to apply causal AI to marketing questions. His latest book is THE TOP 5%.